Choosing the right finish for your woodworking project can be daunting. Two popular options frequently debated are Tru-Oil and tung oil. While both offer a natural, protective finish, they differ significantly in their application, drying time, durability, and overall aesthetic. This in-depth comparison will help you decide which oil best suits your needs and desired outcome.
Understanding the Differences: Tru-Oil vs. Tung Oil
Both Tru-Oil and tung oil are penetrating finishes, meaning they soak into the wood rather than sitting on top like a varnish or lacquer. However, their composition and resulting properties vary considerably.
Tru-Oil: A Proprietary Blend
Tru-Oil is a proprietary blend of drying oils, solvents, and resins developed by Birchwood Casey. Its exact composition is a closely guarded secret, but it's known to contain a modified linseed oil and other additives to accelerate drying and enhance durability. This proprietary blend contributes to its ease of use and relatively fast drying time compared to traditional tung oil.
Tung Oil: A Natural Oil
Tung oil, on the other hand, is a natural oil extracted from the seeds of the tung tree. It's a polymerizing oil, meaning it hardens through a chemical reaction with oxygen, forming a durable film over time. Pure tung oil, however, takes considerably longer to dry and may not offer the same level of protection as a modified or polymerized version. Many commercially available "tung oils" are actually blends that include other drying oils and additives for faster drying and improved performance.
Key Differences Summarized:
| Feature | Tru-Oil | Tung Oil |
|---|---|---|
| Composition | Proprietary blend of oils, solvents, resins | Natural oil from tung tree seeds |
| Drying Time | Relatively fast (24-48 hours per coat) | Much slower (days to weeks per coat) |
| Durability | Good to excellent, depending on application | Good, but can be variable depending on purity and application |
| Application | Easy, thin coats build up finish | Can be more challenging, requires more coats |
| Water Resistance | Good | Good, improves with multiple coats |
| UV Resistance | Moderate | Moderate, improves with multiple coats |
| Cost | Generally more expensive | Generally less expensive |
Application and Finishing Techniques
Applying Tru-Oil:
Tru-Oil is exceptionally easy to apply. Thin coats are rubbed into the wood, allowing it to penetrate deeply. Multiple thin coats are recommended to build up a durable and attractive finish. Excess oil should be wiped off after each coat before it dries.
Applying Tung Oil:
Tung oil application requires more patience and skill. Multiple coats are also necessary, and allowing sufficient drying time between coats is crucial. The process is often described as more involved, requiring more attention to detail and proper wiping techniques to prevent sticky or uneven surfaces.
Choosing the Right Oil for Your Project
The best choice between Tru-Oil and tung oil depends heavily on your project's requirements and your personal preferences.
-
Choose Tru-Oil if: You need a quick-drying, easy-to-apply finish with good durability. It's ideal for projects where time is of the essence or for beginners who want a forgiving finish.
-
Choose Tung Oil (particularly a high-quality, polymerized version) if: You're looking for a more traditional, all-natural finish and are willing to invest the time for a multi-day application process. A high-quality tung oil can offer a beautiful, deep luster and excellent durability over time.
Conclusion
Both Tru-Oil and tung oil provide excellent finishes for wood, but their distinct properties make them suitable for different projects and skill levels. Carefully considering the factors outlined above will help you choose the oil that best meets your needs and allows you to create a stunning, durable, and long-lasting finish for your woodworking masterpiece. Remember that proper surface preparation is crucial for optimal results regardless of the chosen finish.
