The Pietta Great Western II is a replica of the famed 1873 Colt Peacemaker, a revolver that's become iconic in Western lore. But is this Italian-made replica worthy of its legendary namesake? This in-depth review will explore the features, performance, and overall value of the Pietta Great Western II, helping you determine if it's the right firearm for you.
History and Design: Tracing the Lineage of a Legend
The Colt Single Action Army, better known as the Peacemaker, holds a significant place in American history and popular culture. Its robust design and reliable performance cemented its legendary status. The Pietta Great Western II aims to capture this essence, offering a more accessible version of this iconic revolver. While not an exact clone, the Pietta successfully replicates the Peacemaker's key aesthetic features:
- The Silhouette: The instantly recognizable shape and proportions are faithfully reproduced. The overall look and feel evoke the classic Colt, appealing to collectors and enthusiasts alike.
- Action: The single-action mechanism is a defining characteristic, requiring the hammer to be manually cocked before each shot. This adds to the authentic experience but also requires more deliberate handling.
- Material and Finish: The Pietta Great Western II typically uses a blued steel finish, contributing to the gun's classic aesthetic. While not the same high-grade steel as the original Colt, it provides acceptable durability for recreational shooting.
Performance and Handling: On the Range with the Pietta Great Western II
The Pietta Great Western II is primarily designed for target shooting and cowboy action shooting (CAS). Its performance characteristics align with its intended purpose:
- Accuracy: While not a match-grade pistol, it offers acceptable accuracy at typical CAS ranges. Proper sighting and ammunition selection are key to maximizing accuracy.
- Reliability: Like any firearm, proper maintenance is crucial. With regular cleaning and lubrication, the Pietta Great Western II generally provides reliable function. However, minor malfunctions can occur, particularly with cheaper ammunition.
- Recoil: The .45 Colt cartridge delivers a noticeable recoil, especially for those unfamiliar with larger caliber revolvers. This recoil is manageable but should be considered, especially for newer shooters.
Key Considerations for Potential Buyers:
- Ammunition: The .45 Colt cartridge is readily available, but prices can vary. Experimentation with different brands may be necessary to find ammunition that functions reliably in your specific Pietta Great Western II.
- Maintenance: Regular cleaning and lubrication are vital for maintaining the firearm's functionality and longevity. Familiarize yourself with proper cleaning techniques before purchasing.
- Safety: As with any firearm, safe handling practices are paramount. Always handle the Pietta Great Western II responsibly and follow all safety guidelines.
Value and Conclusion: Is the Pietta Great Western II Worth It?
The Pietta Great Western II offers an attractive blend of historical accuracy, aesthetic appeal, and functionality at a significantly more affordable price point than an original Colt Peacemaker. It's a fantastic option for those seeking a fun and historically significant firearm for target shooting or CAS. However, it’s essential to understand that this is a replica, not a collector's-grade original, and its performance may not match that of a meticulously maintained antique.
If you're looking for an affordable and enjoyable way to experience the legacy of the Colt Peacemaker, the Pietta Great Western II is a strong contender. Just remember to prioritize safe handling and proper maintenance to ensure years of reliable service. The price, combined with its engaging shooting experience, makes it a worthwhile investment for many enthusiasts.
